Just been watching a video made by WAG TV about the British membership of the EU and why we should leave. https://vimeo.com/166378572
Some of it made sense; parts were irritating; some of it was an interesting spin. Here's my thoughts as I watched it.
Someone accused the EU of wrecking the British fishing industry by restricting British fleets while allowing other European boats in. No-one mentioned the rampant over-fishing of European waters as a cause for cutbacks; no political mileage in that.
What really came over was the ignorance about the EU - not just in the person in the street, but also in some of the talking heads featured in the film. The theme was "who are the faceless unelected bureaucrats who take decisions?"
It was interesting to hear about the way Germany, under the leadership of Ludwig Erhard, recovered from the Second World War destruction of its industry and infrastructure by deregulating and getting rid of government control (in contrast with the control held in the UK). What wasn't explained was why Germany then allowed itself to be part of an EU that is now seen as over-controlling.
One recurring theme was "oh these things are bad in the EU" - lobbyists, protectionism and so on. It seemed the filmmakers want us to believe that there is nothing like that in the UK. There is! And the US is far worse.
The film suggested that we should free up the market for steel - but the implication was that cheap Chinese imports would be fine - quietly forgetting that it would be the end for British steelmaking at Scunthorpe and Port Talbot.
There was a piece saying how wonderful things are in Switzerland. Some things are good, but the statistics were misleading. The reason wages are higher than in the UK is largely because of the much higher cost of living. A recent survey showed that consumer prices in Switzerland are 58% higher than in the UK (groceries are 93% higher). It was claimed that Swiss unemployment is much lower than in the EU - but despite the stats in the film, it is currently 4.5%, compared with 5.1% in the UK. The main reason for that is that the Swiss severely restrict who can live and work in Switzerland, though the film claimed it is purely because of how successful Swiss industry is and the lack of EU control.
The worst bits? The racial stereotyping of foreign competitors (verging on comedy racism); Kelvin Mackenzie claiming to be the voice of the working man (not in Liverpool, he isn't, and many others despise him); the concern about growing right-wing nationalism across Europe (does UKIP not recognise that many see it in that same light?).
The most positive aspects? The World Trade Organisation is seen as a positive force in breaking down trade barriers - better than the EU. The discussion about world trade gave the feeling that maybe Britain would be better off outside the EU. Much was made of how small the impact is of EU trade deals compared with those of other countries.
The missing bits? No mention of easy travel within the EU, the ability to live anywhere, the facility to get free health care across the EU. Again, no mileage there, perhaps.